"Darn it, Justin, the whole reason I wanted to have this party was to help Ashley feel better!"
For whatever reason, I hadn't put a lot of thought into exactly how Susan would respond to learning about Catalina's magic mark until we started getting close to them actually talking about it. I suspect the most likely reason is I got tunnel vision thinking about other things on her mind.
It's... POSSIBLE she caught me off guard with her response that now feels obvious in hindsight.
Did this affect any of my carefully made plans in any way?! HA HA HA we'll get into that later.