The first comic Previous comic Comic for Friday, August 20, 2004 Next comic Today's comic
comic
 JUL   August 2004   SEP
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
2930311234
567891011

The first comic Previous comic Next comic Today's comic

All sections previous button All sections next button Filler previous button Filler sections next button News button Random El Goonish Shive Comic Button Random El Goonish Shive Comic Button All

EGS Home | EGS:NP Comics | Filler Comics | News
New Readers | FAQ | Tip Jar | Backgrounds | DEShive.com
Forums | Oh No Robot | Fan Art | Mayhem | E-Mail Dan

Bonus Commentary (if any)

I have not actually (successfully) read the Lord of the Rings, but I have read The Hobbit and heard several reviews of all the books in the series, and there does seem to be at least one common element: singing. Just about everybody sings, including the orcs. That's a world dedicated to the arts and drunken singing fun, right there.

Given the series obsession with song and the fact that I was parodying it here, I felt I had to include at least few lines of a song. I don't think LOTR is prone to musical style singing where everybody just magically knows the words, at least not without a wizard's help, so these hobbit versions of Susan and Tedd must have sung this song together before. That ale they're drinking must be some potent stuff.

I'm sure I had some tune in mind for the song when I wrote it, or at least a simple way of singing it, but I'm not certain now what it was. I do recall that some readers took issue with their declaration of a roof overhead, claiming that there aren't really roofs to hobbit homes. Should I have had them say "a hill overhead?" In any case, I could just claim some human bard wrote the darn thing. Or, you know, some guy. Given how prone people are to singing in that universe, an actual bard might be overkill.

Justin's respect for Samwise from Lord of the Rings is one I share, though we would probably disagree on key aspects regarding just how "close" he was with Frodo. Once I saw the movies (again, I failed to read the books), I reached one simple conclusion: Sam is AWESOME and fully deserving of the "brave" title. I know the odds of me spoiling anything for anyone at this point in time are slim, but just in case, I'll leave it at that.

The first comic Previous comic Next comic Today's comic

 
 
Sponsored in Part By:

Copyright and TM 2002-2008 Dan Shive. All rights reserved.
El Goonish Shive: science fiction and fantasy comic book / comic strip / graphic novel / manga.
Keenspot's Privacy Policy - Hosted by Keenspot - Contact Dan Shive